تقارير: المتهم الخامس بجريمة اغتيال الحريري سياسي
Read this story in English
من المتوقع أن يكون المتهم الخامس في جريمة اغتيال رئيس الحكومة الأسبق رفيق الحريري، في التحديث للقرار الاتهامي الذي سيصدره المدعي العام لدى المحكمة الدولية الخاصة بلبنان القاضي دانييل بيلمار، مدنياً سياسياً.
وتوقعت مصادر دبلوماسية مطلعة عبر صحيفة "اللواء" في عددها الصادر صباح الثلاثاء، أن يكون المتهم الخامس الذي أكدته دوائر المحكمة مدنياً سياسياً، له موقع، وليس عنصراً مندمجاً في إطار حزبي ضيّق، أو جهاز أمني سرّي.
وأكد مصدر قضائي دولي للصحيفة عينها أن بيلمار سيصدر تحديثاً للقرار الإتهامي في جريمة اغتيال رئيس الحكومة الأسبق رفيق الحريري، قبل إحالته إلى إنهاء عمله كمدع عام لدى المحكمة في 12 آذار المقبل.
كما كشف المصدر أن أسماء جديدة ستضاف إلى القرار الاتهامي المحدَّث، لكنه تكتم على هوية هؤلاء الأسماء.
وبحسب القرار الاتهامي الصادر عن المحكمة فان اربعة عناصر من حزب الله ضالعون في هذا الاعتداء وصادرة بحقهم مذكرات توقيف من المحكمة الخاصة بلبنان تم تسليمها في 30 حزيران 2011 الى السلطات اللبنانية اضافة الى نشرات حمراء صادرة عن الانتربول.
وكانت قد كشفت معلومات أن بلمار سلم قاضي الإجراءات التمهيدية دانيال فرانسين منذ فترة مسودة قرار اتهامي جديد، مشيرة إلى أنها مرتبطة بجرائم محاولتي اغتيال الوزيرين مروان حمادة والياس المر واغتيال الأمين العام الأسبق للحزب الشيوعي اللبناني جورج حاوي.
08:39 ,2012 شباط 21
152
Anything they will say, just to ignite Lebanon. And it will work.
09:10 ,2012 شباط 21
19
As if the lebanese are not ignited since the creation of lebanon
23:25 ,2012 شباط 21
20
as if your 'realist' view helps change lebanon by repeating the obvious for others to read
20:01 ,2012 شباط 22
00
i was replying to jc, meaning we should really simmer down the idea of "conspiracy", that we do not need a conspiracy to ignite us and we should quit throwing our garbage and internal conflicts on others. The assasins are from the same house and the conflict is over a 1000 years old between sects before the creation of israel. We hope the STL can be an incremental push towards a more civilized political environment where assasination is no longer a political tool.
09:22 ,2012 شباط 21
85
Let me change my comment since it is not realistic. When we find out the names of the killers. Lebanon will prosper. All the problems will be gone. Disney will be putting a new theme park. Hizballah will be integrated in it as employees carrying roses to greet visitors. What else can I say. It will be a wonderful life.
09:59 ,2012 شباط 21
16
So JC what do you really suggest ? What is relistic ? Do we not try bring some sort of normality and Justice to this country or do we continue to live with out trying to improve our current situation.
So plainly your suggesting just let these criminals go, this is Lebanon,what change will it make ?
This is not the mentality of a person who would like to see Lebanon prosper.
13:19 ,2012 شباط 21
32
I am not against the tribunal. Let us say Nasrallah did it, then what? Problems are solved. Already people had been speculating who done it 7 years ago. Or better yet, let us say Bachar did it, what is the difference in the outcome for Lebanon right now.
10:03 ,2012 شباط 21
25
I have never heard anyone suggest that the reason for criminal law is that it will create a "wonderful life" of peace and prosperity. Criminal law holds people accountable for their actions, and that's pretty much it.
13:12 ,2012 شباط 21
23
dear mowaten,
First let me tell you that I myself am on neither side.
But I would like to share something about the legal justice system in the west is different from the legal justice system in the Middle East. In the west, the courts are not biased, but the juries are. The lawyer or law-firm with the most convincing arguments for the jury, wins the case (and often, the richest side is able to hire the best lawyer/law-firm, and wins because of that).
13:12 ,2012 شباط 21
05
As for courts in the Middle East, they are usually under the mercy of political authority because of brute force or money. That does not mean that the western court system is more just in the end than that of the Middle East, but only that the game is played in the form of arguments for the jury, whereas in the Middle East a political power can force the outcome of a court case, or even nullify it after its outcome. For the STL issue, this means that the STL is not something the US can manipulate by forcing the outcome they want, but that the outcome depends on the best arguments which are brought by the best lawyers which money can buy. But in the end, in Western courts, people are innocent until proven guilty beyond reasonable doubts. This means that any circumstantial evidence is just decoration and cannot 'prove' beyond reasonable doubt that the accused has committed the crime.
13:13 ,2012 شباط 21
16
I say fight the STL in court, get brilliant lawyers, and if innocent, you will win, because the court is on your side simple because of 'innocent until reasonable doubts'.
13:33 ,2012 شباط 21
22
@FlameThrower is right. Why the suspense, or they are afraid to reveal the name or they are avoiding problems for Lebanon. Well I speculate it is Bashar, they are waiting for his people to hang him and problem solved.
19:02 ,2012 شباط 21
14
The real perpetrators are your masters ya mowaten Irani and indeed they are laughing it off. You know this, the world knows and I know this but you will continue to say wasn't us, wasn't me, wasn't them long after they are put on trial, convicted and executed. This is the nature of brain washing...we expect no less of you.
08:43 ,2012 شباط 21
26
We have the Iranian thread via the Hizbullah suspects..Let's bet this time the Syrian thread is going to comme to the surface, and that the infernal menage_a-trois will comme clear before everyone eyes!
09:00 ,2012 شباط 21
32
Oh geese... There is plenty of them so called "phony politicians" and are nothing but third rank foot soldiers for the murdering Ali Baba of Damascus and his mob family... Walid Jumblatt has such a notorious "creature" that is very annoying and pathetic to look in his backyard which for some odd reason he still allows to breathe... There is also that one whose last name translates into what Ali Baba used to light up his cave... And I am sure the culprits are money but these two would top my list...
09:58 ,2012 شباط 21
511
@jcamerican
Another great comment of yours...
Soooo.... what do you propose exactly? Forget about the murders? ...or maybe put up a "Lebanese" trial ;)
You're the one living in Disney Land my dear...
In any case, #5 might have trouble hiding...unless he is already...
13:24 ,2012 شباط 21
51
True, I am living in Disney World. But you guys are banking too much on this. JFK got killed and no one knew the real people behind it. I am not saying let the criminals free.
19:10 ,2012 شباط 21
15
FlameThrower there is only one circus, the one playing out in your head where you will wake up tomorrow, there would be no Israel, all the Palestinians have gone home. GMA is president of Lebanon, the USA is invaded by China, IRAN is the new super power and your friends the folks in Da7ieh started paying for electricity.
Keep smoking that crack cocaine dude and may the circus live on forever in your mind.
20:07 ,2012 شباط 21
13
pfff...same as jc... no alternative proposed... it's a circus because so far the outcome doesn't suit you... and the 4G are not aquitted... and I don't know the truth, but nothing is spared to have the best experts from all over the world working on this case, and if the result does not please you you will reject it... typical!
10:57 ,2012 شباط 21
513
have kept quiet for a long time, sick of the crap from jabal amel and the such, bc the truth is near as bashar is soon to be fallen, but: this politician is either Sleiman Franjieh or Wiam Wahhab, the former most likely. No way it is big guys like aoun or berri.
13:27 ,2012 شباط 21
51
My point exactly, no need for this tribunal here, already we know who are the criminals.LOL
12:18 ,2012 شباط 21
42
ya 3youni ya thinker ... think a bit harder and you will realize that you have just puked stupidity. Bahdaltna with your analysis!
Sleiman Franjieh is above these practices and should not be mentioned in the same sequence as the other traitors and thieves you mentioned in your post.
12:31 ,2012 شباط 21
52
This tribunal has named about 40% of the world's population as suspects. It's just about named everyone, organization, regime, country, religion....all but the real murderers!
12:41 ,2012 شباط 21
16
Flame thrower to one day be electricity payer
What major crime has Lebanon ever solved ?
12:43 ,2012 شباط 21
48
Whoever it is, if convicted, should be hung after he fully confesses and gives us the names of the true perpetrators which I suspect to be Nasrallah and Assad.
19:33 ,2012 شباط 21
15
Ya mowaten IRANI your kuds force is much better at terror and interogation...the best of the best.
08:31 ,2012 شباط 22
01
sameer qintar came back from israel very healthy and earned a degree in jail, just imagine what he would look like coming back from syrian jails?? when are we gona be honest with ourselves. When are we gona stop throwing all our garbage on the enemy? how can we free palestine when we are enslaved at home? something to think about mowaten.
12:50 ,2012 شباط 21
24
Unconfirmed reports from as early as 2005 said that Wiam Wahhab came with thinly veiled death threats to former PM Hariri on behalf on his syrian master Assad. Now we are about to know more. This time its not a low key Hizbollah operative who can live his whole life in Dahiye. The lebanese pro-Assad government will have a real challenge at their hands trying to avoid arresting whoever this politician is.
13:10 ,2012 شباط 21
52
How come Der Spiegel and Le Figaro missed this latest "confidential" STL secret and Naharnet and other Hariri Out-of-this-World Newsmedia conglomerate didn't? Reading the comments of the hopeless hopefuls above, one can easily tell that they not only prefect the art of predicting precisely when the Assad regime has fallen? or will fall? but also the art of predicting the names (because the STL joke will go on until everybody who must be named is named (Wiam Wahhab, Nouhad Qal3i, Sleiman Franjieh, Michel Aoun, Said Aql, Chouchou, Ghaleb and Nasser Qandeel, Emile Lahoud, Ziad Rahbani, the four innocent generals again, Oum Kalthoum, Michel Samaha, Imada Marmal, Ghawar al Tochi, Akhwat Chanai...) of those suspects. walla 3an jad m3alla2in bi 7ibal al hawa. EWEEEEEEHA
13:14 ,2012 شباط 21
15
First time I contribute to this site, but care to rebuke the claim made by Mr. Flame Thrower.
Sleiman Franjieh sent the trucks himself.
Sleiman Franjieh approached bkerke shortly after (when the 4 heads were locked in jail) to strike a deal immunising himself.
Last, SF has taken a strong staunch against the tribunal and has hampered its progress.
Now I am no expert and read the same new you all do, but why would an innocent person attempt the above (all widely reported).
just my thoughts, that's all.
We all went to university (judging by the eloquence of the commentators) and all benefit from some extend of critical reasoning. One has to question Franjieh's behavior todate?
Why not wahab? because he is just incapable. The guys has an IQ of 20, how could engineer a complex deal such as this...
14:02 ,2012 شباط 21
13
politician.. non shiite... from the north. and it will not make any problem for lebanon.
19:38 ,2012 شباط 21
16
Kindly do not prounounce the name of our Lord and Saviour Jesus Christ for your amusement. Nobody is mocking your prophet here are they?
Can't people ever be civilized?
15:44 ,2012 شباط 21
01
To Mowaten
What Invisible Witnesss???
What Invisible Prooff???
The Trial hasn't started yet - There is no Witness & No Proof to talk about yet. It is still in the preparation of indightment phase
When the trial starts, then the Prosecutor will bring forth the witnesses & proof, and the defense will have plenty of time to review and cross examine their testimonies and validity.
You are too eager to dismiss the trial before it has even begun...
16:11 ,2012 شباط 21
02
Find out who ordered the cleanup of the scene of the blast before the evidence was collected and you get your answer.
16:47 ,2012 شباط 21
01
Of course the suspect will run and hide in Dahye. This should prove to be very interesting.
The question what will the M8 government do? They must act with responsibility or face big problems.
They say be careful what you wish for because you might just get it. M8 wanted a coup so they could take the government.....they got it.
18:03 ,2012 شباط 21
02
How about we send him to Syria ya Mouwaten ya Fitih inte?
in Syria no tortures !!!!!!!!
She3let zaka ou feltene inte mouwaten
18:12 ,2012 شباط 21
02
no not as simple as you think moooo.
They did it and it s clear for everyone to see apart from few brainwashed ppl who up till now they cant even acknowledge crimes committed by the Syrians.
Any kidnapped in Syrian jails?Of course not.
Coucou land not Disney land
18:28 ,2012 شباط 21
02
SHN - August 10, 2006: "I would not deny that HA's wish is to establish an Islamic Republic system one day, because we believes that establishing an Islamic government is the only way to bring stability to a society and is the only way to settle social differences, even in a society that is composed of numerous minorities."
18:53 ,2012 شباط 21
04
I have no proof whatsoever and this is only a guess: EMILE LAHOUD
18:54 ,2012 شباط 21
23
Who cares! - when are they going to get to the Pierre Gemayel File!!!
When the STL confirms the killers of Pierre Gemayel - expect Lebanon to become a war zone.
No one cares about Hariri or the others enough.. they were sucking Lebanon dry anyways...
Remeber the international plan against Lebanon is to remove the Christians and everything stems from that!
19:00 ,2012 شباط 21
20
Wish the tribunal give us the name of rafic s killer so we know at least who is this guy or state that drove the occupiers out and freed the Lebanon of syrians
The killer should be judged and later we should honor him for liberating our country
19:42 ,2012 شباط 21
15
Go back and read the booklet the Hzb of El Kzb & Erhab released in the early 80's. Until your leadership denounces these stances and revoke this booklet, these truths remain self evident....ah whatever, I forgot I am talking to the poster child of IRANIAN brain washing experiments.
19:49 ,2012 شباط 21
13
It could even be you ya mowaten IRANI right?...The only problem with that theory is it would mean your masters didn't pay you for the job and that is the only reason you're wasting your wonderful talents typing away at us from your luxury suite in the sewer beneath Da7ieh and just a stone's throw away from your master's underground palace, otherwise you'd be after him for non-payment.
19:56 ,2012 شباط 21
15
for Pierre Gemayel it is clear: quawmieh with support from hizbushaitan.
20:59 ,2012 شباط 21
01
Most of March 8th politicians are nervous now. I hope they delay the indictment for a while to keep those so called politicians on the edge.
I personally think it is Emile Lahhoud.
21:53 ,2012 شباط 21
13
justice is coming and idiots will continue to post on here. the same idiots who have no concern or mercy for the syrian blood being spilled right now!
22:43 ,2012 شباط 21
02
Flame thrower one day will become electricity payer
Between 2005 & 2010 who obstructed the govt.
Finally regardless of the year when did Lebanon ever solve. A major crime
00:21 ,2012 شباط 22
02
@ Mowaten, very personal question: Have you ever lived outside Lebanon. I am just curious if we can have the same view of international justice when we have some experience living in a civilized country? In my opinion (and sorry if it sounds insulting and arrogant) your view is very distorted.
02:56 ,2012 شباط 22
02
It's clear that Hezbollah is THE accessory in Hariri's murder. Perhaps even the mastermind. During the Cedar revolution, we kicked out the Syrians. Then, Hezbollah felt the heat, hence vulnerable. They initiated the war of 2006. Their display of 'power' was no more a way to legitimize their own existence in Lebanon. May 7th 2008 against the other Lebanese factions (after a 17month-long political crisis/sabotage).Since then, they toppled the Hariri Gov, and they are now in power fighting for its survival because it still feels threatened. I do hope the STL will dig deep enough to unveil the truth!
08:36 ,2012 شباط 22
02
the war of 2006 was a miscalculation on hizb's part and thus the "law kuntu a3lam" , the reason behind it was to fend off all the lebanese calls for surrendering the arms, the 2006 was meant to keep some room for resistance maneuvering and thus arms legitimacy. That has all evaporated after 06 and the law kuntu a3lam. The hizb had a much much easier time convincing the lebanese about resisting israel (rightly so) pre-2000 when you barely heard any propaganda about keeping arms etc. it has currently sadly transformed to the equivalent of jaish mahde in iraq, the hizb now openly boasts about iranian support, something unheard of in the 90's.
04:17 ,2012 شباط 22
02
My guess its Sleiman Franjieh who cooperates with all Syria and Hizbollah's dirty work
